Tile and metal can both be Class A on their own. Both also outlast asphalt shingles in the home inspectors' lifespan chart. They differ on weight, on the pitch they need and on what happens when someone climbs up. Every figure below comes with its source.
The short version
- Tile lasts longer, because InterNACHI's chart gives clay and concrete tile 100 years or more against 40 to 80 years for metal.
- Tile weighs 600 to 950 pounds per 100 square feet by the tile industry's figures, while the metal industry says steel weighs half as much as asphalt.
- Tiles often outlast the fasteners and battens under them, so redoing a tile roof can mean relaying the same tiles on new layers.
- Pick metal for a low-pitched roof or a house framed for shingles, but have the framing inspected before tile goes on a house that's never had it.
Metal and tile side by side
| Metal | Tile (clay or concrete) | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical lifespan | 40 to 80 years, copper 70 or more (InterNACHI) | 100 years or more (InterNACHI). About 100 years for clay (National Park Service) |
| Weight per square (100 sq ft) | Steel weighs about half as much as asphalt (Metal Roofing Alliance). Copper is 100 to 125 lb (tile alliance) | Clay 600 to 950 lb, concrete 700 to 950 lb (Tile Roofing Industry Alliance) |
| Minimum pitch California's code allows | 1/4 in 12 for standing seam. 3 in 12 for metal shingles | 2 1/2 in 12, with 2 layers of underlayment up to 4 in 12 |
| Fire rating | Standing seam steel can be Class A on its own | Flat or barrel tile can be Class A on its own |
| Walking on it | Ask the installer which parts of the panel can take a foot | Step only on the bottom 3 inches of each tile. Most makers don't warrant breakage from foot traffic |
| Over the old roof | Can often go over an existing roof, up to the code's limit on layers | Can go over existing asphalt shingles if the building official agrees. Nothing can go over an existing tile roof |
| Solar | Mounts can clamp to standing seams without drilling | Mounts through the tile need tile flashing and deck flashing |
| Installed cost in a 2023 study | $18.68 a square foot for standing seam steel (Headwaters Economics, northern California) | Not priced. The study says tile costs more than composition shingles |
The weights come from 2 trade groups, one for each material. The tile group calls its figures approximate. The code rows come from the 2025 California Residential Code, which applies to permit applications dated on or after January 1, 2026, according to the state's housing department.
Which roof lasts longer?
Tile does. The Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart from InterNACHI, the home inspectors' association, lists clay and concrete tile at 100 years or more. It puts metal at 40 to 80 years and copper at 70 or more. Those figures assume regular maintenance.
The National Park Service says clay tile generally lasts about 100 years, "and often several hundred." The tile industry's trade group goes further. It says a tile roof "can reasonably be expected to outlast the building it protects."
The metal industry's numbers are lower but still long. The Metal Roofing Alliance says metal roofing "lasts 50-plus years." It cites research from the Metal Construction Association saying coated standing seam steel "can last up to 70 years."
There's a catch on the tile side, which the next sections come back to. The tile itself is rarely what wears out first.
Verdict: tile wins on lifespan. Metal still outlasts every asphalt shingle in InterNACHI's chart.
How much does each roof weigh?
Tile is far heavier. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance puts clay tile at 600 to 950 pounds per square and concrete tile at 700 to 950. A square is 100 square feet. Even the lightest tile in that table weighs more than the heaviest asphalt shingle, which tops out at 425 pounds.
Metal goes the other way. The Metal Roofing Alliance says metal roofing "weighs half as much as asphalt." The tile group's own table puts copper at 100 to 125 pounds per square.
That gap matters most when you switch materials:
- From tile to metal. The roof gets much lighter, so the framing that held tile up has weight to spare.
- From shingles or metal to tile. The tile group says that if a home "hasn't previously had a tile or slate roof, an inspection will determine if more support is needed." It adds that reinforcement usually costs a small part of the project.
The Park Service gives the history behind this. Wood shingles took over in the 1800s partly because they were "much lighter, and required less heavy and less expensive roof framing." Many California houses built for shingles were framed the same way.
You can get the look of tile without the weight. The Metal Roofing Alliance says metal tile "has the graceful curves of classic tile, but the lightness and strength of metal." It also lists stone-coated steel tile.
Verdict: on a house framed for shingles, metal is the long-life roof that doesn't need a framing check. Tile needs one first.
Is a tile roof safe in an earthquake?
The tile industry says yes when it's installed to code. Its trade group summarizes a University of Southern California study. The study found that tile installed under the Uniform Building Code "can withstand forces two to three times those generated by the January 1994 Northridge, California earthquake."
The trade group sells the full report, so we couldn't read its methods. Treat the claim as the industry's own.
The fastening makes the difference. The Park Service says roofs in areas prone to earthquakes may have every tile secured with both a nail and a metal clip. Ask your roofer how each tile will be attached, and whether the plan meets the current code.
Can you walk on a tile roof?
You can, but the tile group recommends leaving it to a trained roofing professional. Its technical brief on walking says "most manufacturers specifically do not warrant breakage due to foot traffic."
It says to step on the bottom 3 inches of each tile, where the tile below supports it. Feet should point along the ridge. On high, S-shaped tiles, the brief says to put your heel and toe on the high points of 2 tiles. It also says to stay off hips and valleys, where the tiles are cut and harder to replace.
A broken tile needs fixing fast. The brief says broken tiles "should be replaced as soon as possible" to protect the underlayment from water and the sun.
That's why foot traffic counts in this comparison. Every trip to a chimney, a vent or a solar panel is a chance to crack tile. The tile group says to place antennas, solar panels and other equipment "to minimize roof traffic."
Solar works on both roofs, but it goes on differently:
- On metal, the Metal Roofing Alliance says mounts can attach to the raised seams of a standing seam roof, "eliminating the need to drill holes."
- On tile, the tile group says any mount that goes through the tile or the deck needs "both primary roof tile flashing and secondary deck flashing."
Matching a broken tile can also be hard on an older roof. The tile group publishes a bulletin titled Discontinued Roofing Tiles in North America. If you buy tile, ask for a few spare pieces.
Verdict: metal is easier to live with if people will be on the roof often. Tile is fine for a roof that rarely sees a visitor.
What's under a tile roof?
Underneath the tile, there are fasteners, battens (wood strips the tiles hang on) and underlayment, which is the layer that keeps moisture off the roof deck. On a tile roof, those layers usually give out before the tiles do.
The Park Service says a clay tile roof "most commonly fails due to the breakdown of the fastening system." It says clay tiles "frequently outlast their fastening systems." It's "not uncommon for old tile roofs to be stripped of all their tiles in order to re-lay the tiles with new fastenings and battens."
So a quote to redo a tile roof may not mean new tile. Often it means lifting the tiles, replacing what's under them and putting sound tiles back. The tile group's installation manual says cracked or broken tiles have to come off the roof. Damaged or rusted flashing gets replaced.
You also can't skip the tear-off on a tile roof. California's 2025 Residential Code doesn't allow a new covering over existing clay or concrete tile.
Metal works more like other roofs here. The Headwaters Economics study says replacing any roof covering involves replacing the underlayment. The Metal Roofing Alliance says metal "can often be installed over an existing roof." The code bars a new layer where the roof already has 2 or more.
For how a relay works, step by step, see our explainer on replacing the underlayment on a tile roof.
Which works on a low-pitched roof?
Metal does. Pitch is how many inches a roof rises for every 12 inches it runs. California's 2025 Residential Code lets a standing seam metal roof go as low as 1/4 in 12, which is close to flat.
Tile needs at least 2 1/2 in 12 under the same code. Between that and 4 in 12, it needs 2 layers of underlayment. The tile group's own installation manual is stricter. It says tile below 3 in 12 "shall be considered decorative" and needs a membrane roof underneath.
The Park Service explains why. It says some tile shapes "are not themselves completely water-repellent when used on very low-pitched roofs."
Not all metal goes that low. The code puts metal shingles and lapped panels without sealant at 3 in 12. Our comparison of standing seam and exposed fastener metal roofs goes through the panel types.
Verdict: on a roof below 3 in 12, standing seam metal is the long-life choice.
How do they compare on fire, heat and salt air?
Fire. They're close. A 2024 Headwaters Economics study names flat or barrel tile and standing seam steel as roofs that can be Class A on their own. Class A is the top fire rating. Where tile or metal leaves gaps at the roof's edge, California's wildfire building rules require a noncombustible bird stop to keep embers out. If your home is on the FAIR Plan, its discount sheet lists concrete or clay tile and metal as Class A roofs.
Heat. Both trade groups make energy claims about their own material. The tile group says tile roofs "reduce direct heat transfer by up to 50%." The metal group says bare metal reflects more sunlight than asphalt and sells cool-metal finishes. Either way, check the energy code. The Cool Roof Rating Council says California's cool roof rules apply to single-family roof recoverings and vary by climate zone and slope. Any product used to meet them must be rated by the Council.
Salt air. The code says metal roofing has to be naturally corrosion resistant or have a coating that makes it so. The Metal Roofing Alliance says all steel roofing gets a metallic coating against rust. It calls aluminum "an ideal choice for homes built in marine and coastal environments," because it resists corrosion better than steel. That's the industry's claim, so ask for the panel's coating and warranty in writing if you live near the ocean.
What does each roof cost?
Metal has the clearer public numbers. The Headwaters study priced standing seam steel with a fire-resistant underlayment at $18.68 a square foot. That's from 2023 construction cost data for northern California, including tear-off, labor and overhead. The study says southern California generally ran within 10% of that.
It didn't price tile. It said steel panels or tile "will cost more than asphalt fiberglass composition shingles," which it priced at $6.29 a square foot.
The trade groups each make their own case. The Metal Roofing Alliance says a metal roof costs "roughly two to three times what an asphalt shingle roof costs." The tile group says tile, per year of use, is "the same or less expensive than several other roofing materials." Both claims come from the industry selling the product.
We didn't find a public, recent installed price for tile in California. Get bids on both, with the same scope written out. Our guide on how to compare roofing bids goes through them line by line.
What does the new roof change on your insurance?
Before you sign a bid, ask how your insurer treats the roof you're picking. Since October 14, 2022, a state regulation has required standard insurers that price wildfire risk to reflect a Class A fire-rated roof in their rating plans. Each insurer also files its own rules on which roofs it accepts.
Casa, whose team runs this site, explains those rules in its guide to roof age limits. The guide says tin, copper and corrugated metal roofs are often refused, so check the exact metal before you commit. It also says to keep the permit, the invoice and the roofer's fire rating certificate.
After the roof goes on, the Department of Insurance says to tell your insurer or agent about the work. You may need to show proof, or the insurer may inspect. If you want quotes on the house with its new roof, Casa checks standard insurers first and then specialty insurers. A licensed agent reviews each quote.
Which roof fits your house?
Here's our pick for each common case:
- Your house has tile now and the framing is sound. Stay with tile. Ask whether the tiles can be relaid on new underlayment and battens before you pay for new ones. Our concrete vs clay tile comparison helps if you're buying new.
- Your house was framed for shingles. Choose metal. It's the long-life roof that weighs less than the shingles it replaces, by the metal industry's figures.
- You want tile on a house that's never had it. Have the framing inspected first, as the tile group advises.
- Your roof is close to flat. Choose standing seam metal. The code lets it go to 1/4 in 12, while tile needs at least 2 1/2 in 12.
- You'll have solar or other equipment that people service. Lean toward metal. Standing seam takes clamp-on mounts. Every visit to a tile roof risks a broken tile.
- You want the longest possible life. Choose tile. It has the longest figures of any roof in this comparison.
For where both fit among every common roof, see roof materials ranked for California homes.
Questions people ask
Is metal or tile better for a California house?
It depends on the framing and the pitch. Tile lasts longer, at 100 years or more in InterNACHI's chart. Metal weighs far less and can go on a roof as low as 1/4 in 12 as standing seam.
Can I put a metal roof over my old tile roof?
No. California's 2025 Residential Code doesn't allow a new roof covering over existing clay or concrete tile. The tile has to come off first.
Do I need to reinforce my roof for tile?
Maybe. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance says a home that hasn't had a tile or slate roof before needs an inspection to see whether it needs more support. Tile weighs 600 to 950 pounds per square, by the same group's figures.
Is a metal roof loud in the rain?
The Metal Roofing Alliance, a trade group, says there's little difference between metal and other materials when it comes to noise from rain or hail.
Why does my tile roof leak if the tiles look fine?
The layers under the tile usually fail first. The National Park Service says clay tile roofs most commonly fail because the fastening system breaks down. It also says a broken tile lets water get into the roof below it.
Sources
- Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for HomesInterNACHI
- Preservation Brief 30, Historic Clay Tile RoofsNational Park Service
- Why Weight MattersTile Roofing Industry Alliance
- Why Weight MattersTile Roofing Industry Alliance
- Why Weight MattersTile Roofing Industry Alliance
- Why Weight MattersTile Roofing Industry Alliance
- Why Weight MattersTile Roofing Industry Alliance
- Why Weight MattersTile Roofing Industry Alliance
- Why Weight MattersTile Roofing Industry Alliance
- FAQsMetal Roofing Alliance
- MaterialsMetal Roofing Alliance
- StylesMetal Roofing Alliance
- SolarMetal Roofing Alliance
- Retrofitting a Home for Wildfire Resistance (2024)Headwaters Economics
- 2025 California Residential Code, chapter 9 (UpCodes viewer)UpCodes
- Information Bulletin 2025-03California Department of Housing and Community Development
- California Title 24Cool Roof Rating Council
- Wildfire Hardening DiscountsCalifornia FAIR Plan
- 10 CCR 2644.9Legal Information Institute
- Safer from Wildfires regulation FAQCalifornia Department of Insurance




