Comparisons and rankings for California homes

Issue 1 · Monday, November 16, 2026

How to compare two home insurance quotes

Make the 2 quotes match before you look at the price. That means the same facts about the house, the same policy form, the same limits and the same deductibles. Then the gap in price tells you something.

A taupe two story house with a long driveway
Two quotes for the same house only compare once they describe it the same way.

A lower price on one quote can mean a cheaper policy. It can also mean a smaller dwelling limit, a bigger deductible or a policy that pays less after a fire. You can't tell which from the price alone, so the 10 steps below go through each quote line by line. There's a worksheet at the end to copy.

The short version

  • Compare 2 quotes only after they describe the same house on the same form, with the same limits and deductibles.
  • Ask how each insurer got its dwelling limit, because a lower limit can be most of a lower price.
  • Compare the total for the year with every fee in it, including the 3% tax on a surplus lines policy.
  • Before you pay, check that the binder shows the limits, deductibles, insurer and dates you were quoted.

What do you need before you start?

Gather these for each quote:

  • The quote summary or proposed declarations page. It should list every limit and deductible.
  • The California Residential Insurance Disclosure. State law requires it before or with the application. The agent or insurer marks on it which coverages you chose (Insurance Code section 10102).
  • The replacement cost estimate, if you were given a rebuilding figure. An agent or insurer that gives you an estimate has to give you a copy at that time. A figure given by phone has to be followed by a copy in the mail within 3 business days (10 CCR 2695.183).
  • Your own notes on the house. Write down the square footage, the year built, the roof material, the roof's age and any major updates.

If you only have one quote so far, ask for a second one that starts from the same facts. Give the second agent your notes on the house, plus the dwelling limit and deductibles from the first quote. Casa quotes California homes with standard insurers first and then specialty insurers, and a licensed agent reviews every quote. You can start a request with Casa, whose team runs this site, and run whatever comes back through the 10 steps below.

Step 1. Check that both quotes describe the same house

Every quote is priced from what the insurer was told about the home. Find the property details on each one and compare them. Look at the square footage, the year built, the construction type, the roof material, the roof's age and any detached buildings.

Say one quote lists 1,800 square feet and the other lists 2,100. The dwelling limits won't match, and neither will the prices.

Fix any mismatch first by asking the agent to requote with the right facts. A quote that's built on wrong facts doesn't tell you anything, even when its price looks good.

Step 2. Match the policy form and the kind of insurer

Look for the form name or number on each quote, such as HO 3, HO 5 or DP 3. The forms differ on which causes of damage they pay for, on the house and on what's inside it.

If the 2 quotes are on different forms, you're comparing different products. Our ranking of the homeowners policy forms from HO-1 to HO-8 shows how they differ.

Then check who's writing each policy. An admitted insurer is licensed in California. A surplus lines insurer isn't licensed in California, but it's licensed in another state or jurisdiction (Surplus Line Association of California).

The Department of Insurance says surplus lines insurers aren't backed by CIGA, California's guaranty fund (CDI residential insurance guide). CIGA pays claims when a member insurer becomes insolvent (CIGA).

If one quote is admitted and the other is surplus lines, write that down, because the paperwork changes too. We list those changes in admitted vs surplus lines: 6 differences on your policy.

Step 3. Compare the dwelling limit and how each insurer got it

The dwelling limit (Coverage A) is the most an insurer will pay to rebuild the house. When one quote's limit is lower, part of its lower price comes from paying less after a loss.

Ask how each insurer arrived at its number. In California, a replacement cost estimate has to include these costs (10 CCR 2695.183):

  1. Labor, building materials and supplies
  2. Overhead and profit
  3. Demolition and debris removal
  4. Permits and architect's plans
  5. The features of your house, including the square footage of the living space and its location

The same rule doesn't require the agent to tell you whether the estimate is enough. So put the 2 estimates side by side and look for the line where they differ. Check the square footage and the quality of finishes each one assumed.

The state disclosure form also says the cost to rebuild should be adjusted each year for inflation. An estimate from a few years ago is probably out of date.

Before you go on, ask for both quotes at the same dwelling limit. Use the limit you think is right for the house.

Step 4. Compare how each policy pays to rebuild

A pair of quotes can show the same dwelling limit and still pay very differently. The state disclosure form describes these ways a policy can pay for the house:

Payment basis What the state disclosure form says What to write down
Replacement cost It pays to repair or replace the home, up to the policy's limits. Whether it pays actual cash value until you begin or finish repairs. The form says many policies do.
Extended replacement cost It pays above the dwelling limit, up to a stated percentage or dollar amount. The percentage or the dollar figure on each quote
Actual cash value It pays the cost to repair or replace, less depreciation for the condition at the time of the loss. Whether any part of the policy, such as the roof or your belongings, is paid this way
Building code upgrade (ordinance or law) It pays the extra cost of rebuilding to the codes in effect at the time of the loss. The limit, or that the quote doesn't include it. The form warns these costs may otherwise be excluded.

Source: Insurance Code section 10102

Step 5. Write down every other limit in dollars

A homeowners policy has more lettered parts after the dwelling. Some quotes show them in dollars, but others show percentages. Turn each one into dollars so the 2 quotes line up.

The Department of Insurance says Coverage B (other structures) is normally limited to 10% of Coverage A. It says Coverage D (loss of use) is normally limited to 20% of Coverage A. On a $600,000 dwelling limit, those usual percentages come to $60,000 and $120,000.

The state disclosure form adds that the limits for contents, other structures, living expenses and debris removal are usually a percentage of the dwelling limit. So if the dwelling limit is too low, those limits probably are as well.

For your belongings (Coverage C), check 2 more things:

  • How they're paid. Contents can be covered at replacement cost or at actual cash value, depending on the contract.
  • The special limits. The CDI guide says coverage is limited for property like jewelry, furs and silverware. If you own something valuable, ask each agent what it costs to schedule it with an endorsement.

Liability (Coverage E) and medical payments to others (Coverage F) are dollar amounts, so copy them across as they appear. Our guide to the 6 lettered parts of a homeowners policy explains what each one pays for.

Step 6. Line up the deductibles

Find every deductible on each quote. A policy can list one deductible for most losses and a separate one for a particular kind of damage. If a deductible is written as a percentage, ask what it's a percentage of and work out the dollar amount.

Deductibles can explain a price gap. The CDI guide says a larger deductible may significantly reduce your premium. A quote with a $5,000 deductible isn't the same deal as one with a $1,000 deductible, so ask for both at the deductible you'd pick.

Step 7. Read the endorsements and exclusions

The Department of Insurance's coverage comparison tool shows insurers' basic policy contracts. It doesn't include the optional endorsements an insurer may offer. It also says your actual policy decides your coverage. That's why the endorsements on your quote matter.

Go through the endorsements on each quote and mark any that one has and the other doesn't. Pay attention to water and earthquake:

  • Water. The CDI guide lists mold and water damage from seepage or leaks as not covered. It lists sudden and accidental water damage as covered. Ask whether either quote adds or limits coverage for water.
  • Earthquake. The CDI guide says the insurer has to offer you earthquake coverage for an additional premium. Check whether each quote prices it. Then compare that price on its own.

Step 8. Add up the whole year's cost

Compare the total for the year with every fee in it, rather than the premium line alone. Look for policy fees, broker fees and any charge for paying in installments.

The CDI guide says an insurer's own installment plan is often cheaper than a separate premium finance company.

A surplus lines quote has 2 more charges. As of November 16, 2026, California's surplus lines tax is 3% of the premium. The stamping fee adds 0.18% (Surplus Line Association of California). Look for both as separate lines on the quote.

Our walkthrough on reading a surplus lines quote line by line goes through each fee. The piece on minimum earned premium explains what you'd get back if you cancelled early.

Step 9. Look up the insurer and the person selling it

The Department of Insurance's Company Profile search shows an insurer's location, complaint history and financial strength. The CDI guide also says to check that the agent or broker has a valid license, which you can do on the Department's website.

The Department also publishes premium surveys. Its list includes the 2026 homeowners results (CDI premium surveys). They give sample premiums from insurers licensed in California for set example homes.

The Department says the survey results aren't quotes. Some admitted insurers aren't in the surveys either. The surveys can give you a rough sense of the range, but they won't tell you what your house costs to insure.

Step 10. Choose one, then check the binder

Once the quotes match on the house, the form, the limits and the deductibles, you're left weighing the price, the fees and the insurer itself.

When the binder or application comes back, hold it next to your worksheet. The CDI guide says to make sure it shows the limits and deductibles, the coverage you bought, the insurer's name and the effective and expiration dates. If anything changed from the quote, ask about it before you pay.

The worksheet

Copy this table and fill in a column for each quote. Write every limit in dollars.

Line Quote A Quote B
Insurer name
Admitted or surplus lines
Policy form (HO 3, HO 5, DP 3 or other)
Square footage, year built and roof age the quote used
Dwelling limit (Coverage A)
How the dwelling is paid (replacement cost, extended percentage, actual cash value)
Building code upgrade limit
Other structures (Coverage B)
Personal property (Coverage C) and how it's paid
Loss of use (Coverage D)
Liability (Coverage E)
Medical payments (Coverage F)
Each deductible, in dollars
Endorsements added
Exclusions that matter for your house
Premium for the year
Taxes and fees
Installment or finance charges
Total for the year

Questions people ask

Why is one quote so much cheaper than the other?

Check the house facts, the dwelling limit and the deductibles first (steps 1, 3 and 6). A lower price can come from a smaller limit or a bigger deductible rather than a cheaper policy.

Can I ask an agent to change a quote so it matches the other one?

Yes. Ask for the same dwelling limit and the same deductible as the other quote. The insurer may not offer exactly the same limit or deductible, but asking is how you find out.

My policy ends soon. Which steps matter most?

Start with the house facts, the dwelling limit, the deductibles and the total for the year (steps 1, 3, 6 and 8). Check the binder before you pay. Make sure the new policy starts by the day the old one ends.

Is a surplus lines quote comparable to an admitted one?

Yes, with the same steps. Write down the 2 differences from steps 2 and 8, which are California's guaranty fund and the extra tax and stamping fee.

Can I trust a quote from an insurer that isn't licensed in California?

A surplus lines insurer isn't licensed in California, but it's licensed in another state or jurisdiction. CIGA doesn't back it, so ask for the insurer's financial strength before you choose it.

Sources

  1. section 10102California Insurance Code
  2. Insurance Code section 10102California Public Law
  3. 10 CCR 2695.183California Code of Regulations
  4. Residential Insurance guideCalifornia Department of Insurance
  5. About CIGACIGA
  6. Homeowners, Renters and Condominium Owners Coverage ComparisonCalifornia Department of Insurance
  7. Premium comparison surveysCalifornia Department of Insurance
  8. Company Profile searchCalifornia Department of Insurance
  9. FAQs: insurersSurplus Line Association of California
  10. Broker taxes and feesSurplus Line Association of California

Written by CoverageMog staff. If you spot something out of date, our editorial standards say how we fix it.