Comparisons and rankings for California homes

Issue 1 · Monday, November 16, 2026

Admitted vs surplus lines: 6 differences on your policy

An admitted insurer is licensed by California, but a non-admitted (surplus lines) insurer isn't. Both can insure the same house. The paperwork changes in 6 places you can check before you sign.

A two story house with stone trim on a hillside of golden brush
Both kinds of insurer can write a house like this one.

An admitted insurer is licensed by the California Department of Insurance. A non-admitted insurer (also called a surplus lines or specialty insurer) isn't licensed by California. The state doesn't approve its prices. California's guaranty fund also won't pay its claims if it fails.

Both kinds of policy can insure the same house against the same fire. The differences show up in the paperwork, which California law spells out almost line by line. Below are the 6 you'll see on a quote or a policy, then the rules that apply to both.

The short version

  • A non-admitted policy has a bold state notice on its front page saying the insurer isn't licensed by California.
  • A surplus lines policy shows a 3% state tax and, as of November 16, 2026, a 0.18% stamping fee as separate lines.
  • California's guaranty fund (CIGA) doesn't back a surplus lines policy, while it backs an admitted one up to $1 million for damage to the house.
  • Before you sign, ask for the insurer's name and whether it's on California's approved list, called LASLI.

Admitted vs non-admitted at a glance

On your paperwork Admitted insurer Non-admitted (surplus lines) insurer
Licensed by California Yes. It holds a certificate of authority from the Department No. A state notice on the policy says so in bold
State notice you sign None The D-1, signed when you apply
Who places the policy A licensed agent or broker A licensed surplus line broker, after a search of admitted insurers
Rates approved by the state Yes, before they're used No
Tax The insurer pays 2.35% of its premiums to the state A 3% surplus line tax and a 0.18% stamping fee, shown as separate lines
California's guaranty fund (CIGA) Yes, up to $500,000 a claim, or up to $1 million for the house itself No
Cancellation and nonrenewal notice rules Yes Yes, in the Department's reading of the law

1. The front page has a state notice in bold

The first difference is printed on the policy itself. Under Insurance Code section 1764.1, every non-admitted policy has the state's notice on its front page in boldface 16-point type.

You also get the same notice as a separate sheet called the D-1. You sign it when you apply, but you don't sign it again when the policy renews.

The notice has 8 numbered items. The ones that matter most say the insurer isn't licensed by California and isn't held to the solvency rules California applies to the insurers it licenses. They also say California's guaranty funds won't pay your claims if the insurer can't.

The D-1 comes with 2 rights. If you needed coverage within 2 business days and got the notice only after the policy started, you can cancel within 5 days of receiving it. If you never got one to sign, you can cancel the policy.

Either way, your premium is prorated and any broker's fee comes back to you. The broker has to keep your signed copy for at least 5 years and show it to you if you ask.

An admitted policy doesn't come with any of this, because the notice is required only for non-admitted insurers.

2. The insurer isn't licensed by California

An admitted insurer holds a certificate of authority from the Department of Insurance. That's the legal meaning of "admitted" in section 1063.1.

A non-admitted insurer can still insure a California home, but only through a surplus line broker and only if it qualifies one of 2 ways. The Department keeps a List of Approved Surplus Line Insurers (LASLI), whose insurers it approves in advance. Other insurers can be "eligible" under section 1765.1 instead.

The Department doesn't approve eligible insurers in advance. California doesn't publish a list of them either, according to the Surplus Line Association of California.

So the name on your policy may not be on any California list at all. That's allowed. The D-1 lists what to check instead. An insurer based in another US state should be licensed there. One based abroad should be licensed by its home country and be on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' list of approved non-US insurers.

Ask for the insurer's name and where it's licensed. Then ask whether it's on LASLI.

Anyone who sells insurance in California needs a license from the commissioner under section 1631. For a non-admitted policy, the Department says a licensed surplus line broker has to make the placement. That's a separate license.

Before a broker places your home with a non-admitted insurer, section 1763 requires a diligent search of admitted insurers that write that kind of policy in California. The search counts as diligent when 3 of them have turned the home down, or when fewer than 3 write that kind of policy at all.

Under the same section, a broker can't use surplus lines just to beat the admitted market on price. A placement is presumed to break the law if its premium is below any premium an admitted insurer would charge, outside a narrow exception.

You'll see the broker on the paperwork too. Under section 1764, a certificate or evidence of coverage for a non-admitted policy is issued in the surplus line broker's name and signed by the broker.

4. The state didn't approve the price

Admitted homeowners insurers need the Department's approval before they use a rate. Under section 1861.05, an insurer that wants to change a rate files a complete rate application. The commissioner can't approve a rate that's excessive, inadequate or unfairly discriminatory.

The Department says non-admitted insurers aren't subject to prior approval of rates. The insurer sets its own price. The state doesn't review it before you see it.

That's why a surplus lines quote can't be checked against a filed rate. Compare it line by line against the other quotes you have. Read its exclusions too, instead of assuming they match your last policy.

Our ranking of homeowners policy forms shows what the standard forms include. Use it to spot what a different wording leaves out.

5. A tax and a stamping fee show up as separate lines

An admitted insurer pays a tax of 2.35% on its California premiums under article XIII, section 28 of the state constitution. The state taxes the insurer, so you don't pay that tax as a separate charge.

A surplus lines policy works differently. Under section 1775.5, the premium is taxed at 3%. The broker pays that tax to the commissioner.

As of November 16, 2026, the Surplus Line Association of California also charges a stamping fee of 0.18% on policies that started on or after January 1, 2023. The association says both have to be shown separately on the policy. The same goes for any later change to the premium and for a cancellation.

The premium the tax applies to includes the policy's other charges, such as a policy fee or an inspection fee. So compare an admitted quote with a surplus lines quote by their totals rather than their premium lines. Our guide to reading a surplus lines quote goes through each of those lines where it appears.

6. California's guaranty fund doesn't back it

CIGA is California's guaranty fund. It pays covered claims when a member insurer fails. Under section 1063, its members are the insurers admitted to write those kinds of insurance. CIGA says its money comes from assessments on them.

Even for an admitted policy, the fund has limits under section 1063.1. The part of a claim over $500,000 isn't covered. Damage to the house itself is covered up to $1 million or the amount the policy would pay, whichever is less. Claims of $100 or less aren't covered at all.

A non-admitted insurer isn't a member. Item 3 of the D-1 tells you so. If it fails, no state fund steps in. Its own finances are the only thing behind your claim, which is why its financial strength rating matters more.

Which one should you take?

Take the admitted policy when an admitted insurer will write your home. You get a rate the state approved and a guaranty fund behind your claims.

Surplus lines is for the homes admitted insurers have turned down. It's regulated insurance, placed by a licensed surplus line broker.

If neither will write the home, the California FAIR Plan is next. The nonrenewal notice in section 678 describes the FAIR Plan as the "insurer of last resort." It also says FAIR Plan policies may not cover liability, theft or water damage.

So before you sign a surplus lines policy, ask the broker which admitted insurers turned the home down. Section 1763 requires that search, so the broker should be able to tell you. Casa quotes California homes with admitted insurers first and then surplus lines insurers, and a licensed agent reviews every quote. If you take a surplus lines policy, Casa's guide to how safe a specialty policy is, from the team that runs this site, shows how to read the insurer's financial strength rating.

What stays the same with either kind of insurer?

Several protections don't depend on the insurer's license.

  • Cancellation and nonrenewal notices. In a 2019 legal opinion, the Department concluded that the state's cancellation and nonrenewal notice rules apply to non-admitted home policies too. The commissioner can exempt a class of risk after a hearing, under section 679.6.
  • The 75-day notice. Under section 678, a nonrenewal notice has to be sent at least 75 days before the policy ends. It has to give the reason and tell you that you can ask the Department to review it.
  • Wildfire moratoriums. After a declared wildfire emergency, insurers can't cancel or refuse to renew a home policy just because it's in the fire area. The rule lasts a year in the ZIP codes in or next to the fire's perimeter. The Department's Bulletin 2026-6, issued August 14, 2026 for the Gann Fire, is addressed to admitted and non-admitted insurers.
  • The Department's help line. The D-1 prints the Department's toll-free number, 1-800-927-4357, for questions about a non-admitted insurer.

How can you tell which one you're holding?

You can tell in a couple of minutes with the quote or the policy in front of you.

  1. Look at the front page. A bold notice saying the insurer isn't licensed by California means it's non-admitted.
  2. Look for a surplus line tax line and a stamping fee line. An admitted quote won't have either one.
  3. Find the insurer's legal name. Ask the broker where it's licensed and whether it's on LASLI.
  4. Ask for the surplus line broker's name and license. It should be on the certificate or evidence of coverage.
  5. If you have 2 quotes, one of each kind, put them side by side. Our method for comparing 2 home insurance quotes walks through each line.

Questions people ask

Is non-admitted insurance legal in California?

Yes. A licensed surplus line broker can place a California home with a non-admitted insurer after a search of admitted insurers. The insurer has to be on LASLI or eligible under Insurance Code section 1765.1.

Is an admitted policy safer than a surplus lines policy?

An admitted policy has 2 protections a surplus lines policy doesn't: a state-approved rate and California's guaranty fund. With a surplus lines policy, the insurer's own finances stand behind your claims, so ask for its financial strength rating.

I needed the policy to start right away. Can I still back out?

Yes, in one case. If coverage had to start within 2 business days and the D-1 reached you only after it started, you can cancel within 5 days of receiving the notice. Your premium is prorated and any broker's fee is returned.

Do I sign the D-1 every year?

No. Under Insurance Code section 1764.1, you sign when the application is accepted. A renewal of that policy doesn't need a new signature.

Can a non-admitted insurer drop me without notice?

Not in the Department of Insurance's reading of the law. Its 2019 legal opinion says the same cancellation and nonrenewal notice rules apply to non-admitted home policies, including the 75-day nonrenewal notice.

Sources

  1. section 1764.1California Insurance Code
  2. section 1763California Insurance Code
  3. section 1764California Insurance Code
  4. section 1775.5California Insurance Code
  5. section 1861.05California Insurance Code
  6. section 1631California Insurance Code
  7. section 1063California Insurance Code
  8. section 1063.1California Insurance Code
  9. section 678California Insurance Code
  10. General Counsel's legal opinion, September 17, 2019California Department of Insurance
  11. Bulletin 2026-6California Department of Insurance
  12. Purchasing groupsCalifornia Department of Insurance
  13. List of Approved Surplus Line InsurersCalifornia Department of Insurance
  14. FAQs: insurersSurplus Line Association of California
  15. Broker taxes and feesSurplus Line Association of California
  16. FAQs: state taxSurplus Line Association of California
  17. FAQs: filing proceduresSurplus Line Association of California
  18. Insurance tax law guideCalifornia Department of Tax and Fee Administration
  19. About CIGACIGA

Written by CoverageMog staff. If you spot something out of date, our editorial standards say how we fix it.