A home warranty is a service contract that fixes the furnace or the dishwasher when it wears out. Homeowners insurance pays when something sudden damages the house, such as a fire or water bursting out of a pipe. The 2 don't overlap. California law bars a home warranty from paying for the damage a failed part causes. The standard homeowners form won't pay for the worn-out part itself.
The short version
- A home warranty repairs systems and appliances that wear out, but California law bars it from paying for the damage a failure causes.
- Homeowners insurance pays for sudden damage to the house, but the standard form excludes wear and tear, mechanical breakdown and the broken appliance itself.
- Slow leaks, settling foundations and termites usually fall between the 2, so neither one pays.
- Mortgage lenders generally require homeowners insurance, while a home warranty is your choice.
Home warranty vs homeowners insurance at a glance
| Home warranty | Homeowners insurance | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A service contract. The Department of Insurance says it isn't an insurance policy | An insurance policy |
| What it pays for | Repairing or replacing listed systems and appliances that fail from wear and tear, deterioration or a defect | Sudden physical damage to the house and your belongings, plus your liability to others |
| What it won't pay for | Damage the failure causes to the rest of the house | Wear and tear, mechanical breakdown and the appliance or pipe the water escaped from |
| Walls, roof and foundation | Generally left out | The main thing it insures |
| What you pay when something happens | A service fee for each request | The deductible on each claim |
| How you start | A phone call, with no claim form required first | A claim with your insurer |
| Needed for a mortgage | No | Lenders generally require it |
What does a home warranty pay for?
A home warranty pays to repair or replace parts of the house that wear out. California law calls it a "home protection contract." Under Insurance Code section 12740, it repairs or replaces a home's systems, components or appliances when they fail from "wear and tear, deterioration or inherent defect."
You pay a set fee for a set period. The Department of Insurance says that period is usually a year.
This article is about one sentence in that same section. A home warranty "shall not include protection against consequential damage from the failure of any component, system or appliance." So when the water heater fails, the contract deals with the water heater. The soaked floor isn't part of it.
The Department's homeowners and renters guide, revised in January 2026, describes what a contract usually includes. That's plumbing, heating, electrical systems and major appliances such as washers, dryers, ovens and refrigerators. Structural parts of the house generally aren't included. Some contracts add items like air conditioners or built-in microwaves for an extra fee.
Every contract has its own list. Under section 12762, it has to name each appliance, system and component it includes and disclose all of its exclusions and limits. If an item isn't on the list, the contract doesn't include it.
A builder's warranty on a new home is a different product. So is a manufacturer's warranty on a new appliance. Section 12741 leaves both of them out of the home warranty law.
What does homeowners insurance pay for?
Homeowners insurance pays for sudden physical damage to the house and the things in it. Many policies are built on the HO-3, a model form written by the Insurance Services Office. Its coverage for the house insures against "direct physical loss" unless the form excludes the cause.
The exclusions are where it parts ways with a warranty. The HO-3 leaves out "wear and tear, marring, deterioration" and "mechanical breakdown, latent defect, inherent vice." It also excludes rust, corrosion, settling foundations and damage by birds, rodents or insects. Faulty or defective maintenance has its own exclusion.
Sudden water from a broken pipe or appliance is still covered. The HO-3 pays for loss from an "accidental discharge or overflow of water or steam" from plumbing, heating, air conditioning, a fire sprinkler system or a household appliance. It even pays to tear out and replace part of the house when that's needed to reach the broken pipe.
It stops at the broken part, though. In the form's words, "We do not cover loss to the system or appliance from which this water or steam escaped."
Your own policy may read differently, because insurers can file their own forms. Our ranking of homeowners policy forms shows how the HO-3 compares with the other forms you might see on a quote.
When one problem needs both
A burst water heater is the Department of Insurance's own example. Its guide says that if the tank bursts and destroys a wall, the warranty would repair the water heater. Homeowners insurance would pay for the damage to the wall and floor.
That split follows the wording on both sides. Section 12740 bars the warranty from paying for consequential damage. The HO-3 pays for the water damage but not for the appliance the water came from. So you'd make 2 calls. Each company would pay its own part.
You'd pay something up front to each of them. The warranty charges a service fee for each request. The policy pays only the part of the loss above your deductible, so damage that costs less than the deductible comes out of your pocket.
If the heater needs replacing anyway, our comparison of tankless and tank water heaters puts the 2 kinds side by side.
Which one pays? 8 common problems sorted
Here's how 8 everyday problems usually split under the HO-3 and a typical home warranty. The wording of your own contract and policy is what counts, so check both before you call.
| Problem | Home warranty | Homeowners insurance |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The furnace stops heating because a part wore out | Usually repairs or replaces it, if heating is on the contract | No. Wear and tear and mechanical breakdown are excluded |
| 2. The refrigerator stops cooling | Usually repairs or replaces it, since major appliances are typical | No, for the same reason |
| 3. The water heater tank bursts and floods the floor | Repairs or replaces the water heater | Pays for the wall and floor, minus the deductible |
| 4. A supply line under the sink splits and sprays water | Usually repairs the pipe, if plumbing is on the contract | Pays for the water damage and for opening the wall to reach the pipe, but not the pipe itself |
| 5. A slow drip under the sink rots the cabinet over months | May fix the drip, but not the rotted cabinet | Usually no. The Department says leaks and seepage generally aren't covered |
| 6. The foundation settles and the slab cracks | No. Structural parts are generally left out | No. Settling and cracking of foundations are excluded |
| 7. Termites damage a wall | No. Damage to the structure is generally left out | No. Insects are excluded |
| 8. A windstorm drops a tree through the roof | No. Nothing wore out | Yes, minus the deductible |
Rows 1 and 2 belong to the warranty alone. Rows 3 and 4 need both. Row 8 belongs to the insurance alone.
Rows 5, 6 and 7 are the ones to worry about, because often neither side pays. Termite treatment is sold separately, as a pest control service agreement. Section 12741 keeps those agreements out of the home warranty law.
The gap in the middle: slow leaks
A slow leak is the clearest case of damage that neither side pays for in full. The warranty can fix the leaking part, but section 12740 bars it from paying for the water damage. The Department's guide lists water damage from seepage or leaks among the things a homeowners policy generally doesn't cover.
Mold makes it worse. The HO-3 excludes mold, fungus and wet rot, unless it's hidden inside a wall, floor or ceiling and came from an accidental discharge of water.
So the best protection against the gap is catching a leak early. Our ranking of water leak detector types compares battery sensors, smart shutoff valves and whole-home flow monitors.
What California law requires of a home warranty
Home warranty companies in California answer to the Department of Insurance, under their own part of the Insurance Code. Here's what that law says, section by section:
- A license. Under section 12744, a company needs a license from the Department to offer home warranties in California, with an exception for some admitted insurers.
- A filed form. Under section 12763, the contract can't be issued until a copy of its form has been filed with the Insurance Commissioner.
- A contract that spells it out. Section 12762 requires the contract to list each included item, all exclusions and limits, its length, its fee, any renewal terms and any service fees.
- Service by phone. You ask for service by phone. Under the same section, the company can't make you file a claim form before the work is done.
- A 48-hour start. Section 12762 also says the company or someone it sends has to start service within 48 hours of your request.
- Limits on cancelling. Under section 12764, the company can cancel during the first term only for nonpayment, fraud or a material misrepresentation. It can also cancel a contract that started before a home sale if the sale doesn't happen. The law doesn't give you a right to renew.
- No free contracts and no tie-ins. Under section 12761, a company can't give a contract away for free. Under section 12760, no home warranty company or insurer can make you buy a home warranty to get another policy when a home is bought or sold.
- Limits on commissions. Section 12760 also bars commissions for selling a contract, except to the company's own employees and sales agents. A real estate licensee who shares in the commission on your home sale can't get one.
A contract can start before you own the home. Section 12761 allows that if you commit to paying the fee when the title transfers. The company may also require an inspection before it issues a contract.
If you have a question about a home warranty company, the Department's consumer line is 1-800-927-4357.
Do you need both?
You need homeowners insurance if you have a mortgage. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says lenders generally require proof of it. Without a mortgage, it's still the one that pays when the house itself is damaged.
A home warranty is a budgeting choice. The Department's January 2026 guide says contracts generally cost about $350 to $400 a year, plus $35 to $50 per service call. Prices vary by company and by what's on the contract.
The same guide says a contract may not be needed when the plumbing, heating, electrical systems and major appliances are new or recently upgraded. In an older home, it says repair costs can add up quickly.
A home's age doesn't generally matter, but its condition does. The Department says covered items have to be in good working order when the contract starts.
Here's our verdict. Keep the homeowners insurance whatever you decide about the warranty, because it's the only one of the 2 that pays for damage to the house. Consider a home warranty when the systems are old and you'd rather pay a known yearly fee than an unknown repair bill.
If you're buying the house, the warranty and the policy both come up before closing. Section 12761 lets a warranty start before the title transfers. Section 12760 bars a warranty company or an insurer from making you buy one to get another policy. The homeowners policy is the one your lender will want proof of, so sort it out first. Casa quotes California homes with standard insurers first and then specialty insurers, and a licensed agent reviews every quote. Casa's guide to the insurance contingency in a purchase contract, from the team that runs this site, explains how long you have to get that answer.
How to tell which one to call
When something breaks, work through these steps to find out who to call.
- Stop the damage. Shut off the water or the power to the failed system. The HO-3 excludes damage that comes from neglecting reasonable steps to protect the house after a loss.
- Ask whether anything else was damaged. If a system or appliance quit and nothing else was damaged, call the warranty company.
- Call your insurer if the house was damaged. If water, fire or a storm damaged walls, floors or your belongings, take photos before you clean up and call your insurer too.
- Read the warranty's list. Check that the failed item is on the contract and that none of its exclusions applies.
- Compare the damage with your deductible. If the damage clearly costs less than your deductible, the policy won't pay anything toward it.
- Keep the paperwork. Ask the technician to write down what failed and why. Keep every receipt too.
Questions people ask
Is a home warranty a kind of insurance?
No. The California Department of Insurance says a home protection contract isn't an insurance policy, even though the Department licenses and regulates the companies that sell these contracts.
Does homeowners insurance pay for a broken water heater?
It doesn't pay for the water heater itself when it wears out or breaks down. Under the standard HO-3, it does pay for damage from water that suddenly escapes from it, minus your deductible.
Will a home warranty pay for water damage from a leak?
No. California Insurance Code section 12740 bars a home warranty from paying for damage that the failure of a system or appliance causes. It can only repair or replace the failed item.
How fast does a home warranty company have to respond?
Under California Insurance Code section 12762, service has to start within 48 hours of your request. You ask by phone. The company can't require a claim form first.
Can a home warranty company cancel my contract?
During the first term, it can cancel only for nonpayment, fraud or a material misrepresentation, or if the contract started before a home sale that didn't happen. California law doesn't give you a right to renew.
Sources
- section 12740California Insurance Code
- section 12741California Insurance Code
- section 12744California Insurance Code
- section 12760California Insurance Code
- section 12761California Insurance Code
- section 12762California Insurance Code
- section 12763California Insurance Code
- section 12764California Insurance Code
- Residential Insurance guideCalifornia Department of Insurance
- Homeowners 3, Special Form, HO 00 03 05 11 (via the Maine Bureau of Insurance)ISO
- What is homeowners insurance?Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Consumer helpCalifornia Department of Insurance




